Restoration Case Study

The Stories Beneath the Surface

A painting, its past, and the decisions that shape its future.

Ref: A326-2026CBA | Tony Ng Conservation Studio

Artist

Khalil Ibrahim

Title

Untitled (Sawah Padi)*

Date

1957*

Medium

Oil on Canvas

Dimensions

34.3 x 49.3 cm

I. The Painting

The painting depicts a rural landscape with trees, open fields, haystacks, and distant mountains. Its composition captures a quiet scene of agricultural life, conveyed through layered colours and carefully observed details.

According to the certificate of authenticity supplied by the owner, the work is titled Landscape 1, associated with Pahang, and dated 1957. The document identifies the medium as oil on canvas and bears a signature attributed to the artist, Khalil Ibrahim.

These details are recorded here as information contained in the owner's documentation. The present case study focuses on the painting's material condition and conservation treatment; it does not constitute an independent authentication or verification of the work's provenance.

The purpose of this study is to document the physical evidence observed during examination, the treatment decisions made in response to that evidence, and the considerations involved in preserving the painting for continued care.

II. The Hidden Damage

A painting's condition is not always fully apparent from its front surface. In this case, examination of the reverse revealed an existing lining canvas, indicating that the painting had undergone an earlier structural intervention.

Raking-light examination showed localized raised or bubble-like deformations across the painted surface. Observations along the edges also indicated spaces between the original canvas and the lining canvas. These findings suggest that the existing lining arrangement was no longer providing uniform contact in all areas.

Other conditions included a canvas tear measuring approximately 2 cm, surface dirt and unidentified deposits, an aged varnish layer, and visible evidence of previous retouching. Microscopic examination also showed cracking and other features associated with the ageing of the paint layer.

UV fluorescence revealed uneven markings across parts of the surface, including areas consistent with previous treatment. However, fluorescence alone cannot establish the precise composition, age, or history of these materials.

The examination also recorded approximate pH readings of 5 on both the painted surface and the canvas reverse, together with an ATP surface reading of 123 RLU. These measurements provide additional information about the condition at the time of examination, but they do not independently establish the cause of deterioration or confirm biological activity.

Taken together, these observations indicated that the painting required attention to both its structural condition and its surface appearance.

III. Understanding the Past

Previous conservation and repair treatments form part of an artwork's material history. Their presence does not, by itself, establish whether an earlier intervention was appropriate or inappropriate in its original context.

For this painting, the existing lining, localized surface deformation, and evidence of earlier repairs were important considerations in planning the treatment. The condition observed during examination suggested that the relationship between the original canvas and its lining required particular attention.

The aim was not to erase every trace of the painting's history, but to address the observed instability while retaining the original painted surface wherever possible.

Treatment decisions were therefore guided by the condition of the materials, the response observed during intervention, and the need to balance structural support with the preservation of existing artistic material.

IV. A New Chapter

The conservation treatment addressed the painting's structural irregularities, localized canvas damage, accumulated surface deposits, and aged varnish.

The existing lining arrangement was treated to address localized deformations and improve the support of the original canvas. BEVA 371 was used in the structural treatment. The approximately 2 cm canvas tear was consolidated and repaired, with Paraloid B-72 used as a consolidant.

Surface cleaning was then undertaken to reduce accumulated dirt and deposits. Controlled solvent treatment was used to reduce the aged varnish layer, following preliminary testing and consideration of the surface's sensitivity.

Areas requiring visual reintegration were treated through localized filling and retouching, where appropriate. A final conservation varnish was subsequently applied to improve colour saturation and provide a protective surface layer.

Each stage served a specific purpose: to address the observed condition, improve the painting's presentation, and retain as much of the original material as practicable.

The treatment outcome is documented in the accompanying before-and-after photographs. These images illustrate visible changes following treatment, although photographic lighting, colour reproduction, and other imaging conditions may affect the apparent differences.

V. Beyond the Surface

"We cannot stop time, but we can care for what it leaves behind."

Conservation is not about making an old painting look entirely new. It begins with understanding the materials, recognising the changes that have taken place, and deciding which interventions are appropriate.

Every painting carries evidence of its making, its ageing, and sometimes the repairs it has received along the way. Some of that evidence can be addressed through treatment; some must be understood and respected as part of the object's present condition.

For this landscape, the work involved more than improving its visible appearance. It required attention to the canvas support, the existing lining, the damaged area, and the aged surface coating before the painting could be visually reintegrated.

The result represents the condition achieved at the completion of treatment, not a promise that the painting will remain unchanged indefinitely. Its future condition will continue to depend on handling, display, and environmental conditions.

The stories beneath the surface remain part of the painting. Conservation helps make it possible for those stories to continue.

VI. Visual Documentation

This section visually documents the artwork's condition and the conservation process.

VII. Beyond the Surface — A Conservation Story

Important Legal & Editorial Disclaimer:

This report is published as part of Tony Ng Conservation Studio's public educational initiative to share real restoration cases and improve public understanding of painting conservation.

Information pertaining to the artwork's title (e.g., "Landscape 1" / "Sawah Padi"), creation date (e.g., 1957), and historical background has been voluntarily supplied by the client/owner through private documentation. Tony Ng Conservation Studio does not conduct independent authentication, valuation, or historical verification. The inclusion of such background narratives does not constitute a certification of authenticity, nor does it confirm a market value or rarity.